Macworld Wish List for Steve
by David Miller12/30/2003
G5s and iMacs and Powerbooks and iBooks. Panther and Keynote and iLife and Final Cut. These are a few of my favorite things.
It's been a busy year at Apple's headquarters; the elves have been busy down in sunny Cupertino, California hacking away on the iTunes Music Store, G5, Mac OS X Panther, and countless other offerings, from the 20" iMac and new Powerbooks and iBooks, to Apple's conferencing duo, iChat AV and the iSight video camera.
It's been a great year (arguably, the best in a long time) for the Cult of Mac, although many of us are left wiping the drool off of our chins as we realize that our wallets just aren't fat enough to pay for that trip to the Apple Store to pick up Apple's new toy. And with the Macworld Conference & Expo coming up in early January, there's a strong chance that the bang that 2003 left behind will echo into 2004. Just think of Steve Jobs' keynote speech as a second Christmas; instead of Santa leaving presents underneath the tree, Steve will be unveiling them during the speech.
|
Related Reading
Mac OS X: The Missing Manual, Panther Edition |
The elves here at O'Reilly's MacDevCenter have spent the entire year trying to keep you, the reader, informed on what's going on in the Macintosh development circles. So forget about sugarplums dancing in our heads; we've been dreaming of what else Steve might have stuffed away in his sled. And so, I'm pleased to present you the wish list of the MacDevCenter editors. But being the Mac-nuts that we are, this list isn't what we'd like for Christmas. Instead, it's a list of what we'd like to see announced in Jobs' keynote on January 6th. Let's just hope he won't be giving socks, underwear, and a tuna-fish necktie as presents to those of us who will be watching the presentation (in person or via streaming broadcast).
Be warned that the list is composed of presents that range from stocking stuffers all the way up to big-ticket items that come with a big bow wrapped around them. Some items on the list might see the light of day, while others are purely pipe dreams; it shouldn't be too difficult to figure out which one is which.
Big-Ticket Items
iOffice
Keynote was released to an unsuspecting public earlier this year. Serving as Apple's first entry into the realm of office applications, Keynote has proven to be very capable and easy to use. But why stop with just a presentation program?
Daniel H. Steinberg would like to see three other applications added to the stable: Document for word processing, Spreadsheet for number crunching, and Account for balancing your books. And like Keynote, each would be fully compatible with their Microsoft Office cousin (or Quickbooks, in the case of Account), and sport a publicly documented XML syntax, akin to APXL, to allow interaction with other XML-aware programs. Since Keynote is already a mature application, the version that ships with Office 1.0 will include new features, such as hyperlinking to other parts of the presentation, in addition to other files such as AppleScripts and web pages.
iPhone
With the iPod, Apple has proven that they can compete in the consumer electronics market. Prior to the iPod's release, many doubted whether Apple would re-enter the market after the Newton was axed.
But after toppling the digital music player market with the iPod, who's to say that Apple won't give the iPod a cousin to play with? MacDevCenter's editor, Derrick Story, would like to see an iPhone that integrates with Mac OS X's applications such as iCal, Address Book, and iPhoto over Bluetooth. And judging by the level of craftsmanship that Apple put into the iPod, the iPhone would certainly be a sought-after item for anyone who is dismayed by the current market of cell phones.
iTerminal
Think of a traditional *nix terminal. Now bring it into the 21st century by replacing the monochrome-green CRT with a touch-sensitive flat-panel, and having it use Airport instead of an Ethernet cable to communicate with nearby Macs. Include Apple Remote Desktop to allow users to create sessions with their main workstations, or to use the iTerminal as a slideshow display for an iPhoto album stored elsewhere on the network.
New Boxen and Hardware
We can always count on new, more powerful machines to be released every year, especially with the first wave of G5 chips hitting the market. 2003 also brought the G4 chip to the iBook, effectively removing the G3 from Apple's product line entirely. Of course, we'd all like to see a Powerbook G5 for under $1,000, but that's just not going to happen any time soon. Maybe some of the following will:
- A G5 XServe
- An XServe geared towards small businesses and independent developers, possibly equipped with the G4 architecture to keep prices down
- A special edition Mac to commemorate the Macintosh 128K's 20th anniversary, complete with retro-styling
- A 30" Apple Display to allow a bazillion documents to be open and viewable at the same time, and capable of doubling as an HDTV set in a pinch
Medium-Sized Presents
iScan
I would love to see an application from Apple that puts to rest all of the shoddy applications for OS X that are bundled with scanners. Not only do the applications look as though they originated in Windows 95, but they also leave a lot to be desired in the usability department.
Ideally, Apple would use the existing TWAIN standard, and include drivers for as many products as possible with iScan's release. Scanner manufacturers could then provide TWAIN drivers for their own products on their web sites.
iPod Additions
The iPod's feature set has expanded with each upgrade to its firmware; it was originally released as a no-frills digital music player with a secret game of Breakout thrown in for good measure. But now that the firmware has reached version 2.1, the iPod can store your contacts, calendar, notes, and even wake you up with the tunes of your favorite playlist.
And the introduction of Belkin's Media Reader and Voice Recorder accessories proved that the iPod can handle tasks that are way beyond the scope of its original purpose. Whether Apple continues down the road of adding more and more functionality to the iPod remains to be seen. Either way, here's what we'd like to see:
- A plug-in keyboard for the iPod to add capabilities traditionally belonging to PDAs
- Bluetooth output and input to wirelessly stream audio to any receivers that may be listening, which would allow a network of iPods to stream music to each other (similar to how iTunes can stream music)
- An adapter to allow the iPod to use a Powerbook or iBook power cord, which would remove one more item from our already packed bags
Entertainment
While OS X really is a joy to use, it has yet to reach the level of "fun." Just about every other operating system includes a series of basic games to pass the time for a short time while a task runs in the background. Whereas Windows introduced Minesweeper and Freecell to the masses, OS X includes a rendition of Chess to fill the void. Which, while enjoyable, is like playing a cricket match for five minutes: it's hard to enjoy when played for such a short period of time.
ADC Membership Levels
Mac OS X includes, at no extra charge, world-class development tools to create applications for the new operating system. However, support via the Apple Developer Connection is available on four different levels (the details are available here):
- Online: A bare-bones membership that is freely available to anyone and includes access to SDKs and resources such as mailing lists and example source code.
- Select: Lodged between the Online and Premier levels, this category gives developers access to everything included in the Online membership, in addition to resources such as pre-release software and operating systems.
- Premier: This category is the top-of-the-line, no-holds-barred, everything-and-the-kitchen-sink combo, and weighs in at $3,500 for an annual membership.
In addition to the above list, Apple provides a Student category for the annual fee of $99.
Andrew Anderson would like to see a Hobbyist/Independent category that is targeted towards one-man operations, providing resources that are available for students to the small developers who can't justify the Select membership when their budgets are considered. The inclusion of the developer tools package in the box for no extra cost is the major reason why OS X has received so much attention from the developer community. Opening up the Apple Developer Connection to these same people who may come from a Java or Windows development background and are tinkering with XCode and Interface Builder could work wonders for application development on OS X.
.mac Services
Several of the elves here at the MacDevCenter would like the .mac applications to become available without having to sign up for the whole package. This would allow consumers to purchase/subscribe to individual applications, such as Backup and iDisk, since they're offered a la carté. Those who wish to use all of the .mac applications could continue to do so with the bulk discount.
New Versions of iLife Applications
The iLife Applications (iTunes, iPhoto, iMovie, and iDVD) really are the top of their class. But there's always room for improvement:
- While Apple wants people to buy SuperDrives to use with iDVD, it would be nice if the application worked with generic and/or external DVD/R drives.
- iPhoto's interface for assigning "keywords" from photos is still confusing.
- As Panther proved, improved performance never hurt anyone.
iLife Framework
Cocoa programmers have had hooks into the system-wide Address Book framework since the application was introduced with Panther. Similarly, the iLife applications have access to each other's libraries, making it easy to place your favorite photos and music into an iMovie project, for example. It would be even cooler if Apple provided an iLife framework that gave Cocoa (and Java) programmers access to the libraries without resorting to parsing the applications' XML library files, as mytunes does.
Stocking Stuffers
Last, but definitely not least, are the small things that we'd like to see from Apple in 2004:
- A "Create Disk Image From Selection" command available via a contextual menu in the Finder.
- A "Recent Files" menu item to accompany the "Recent Projects" item in XCode.
- The ability to enable/disable tracks on a per-playlist basis in iTunes, rather than throughout the entire library.
- Thorough AppleScript support for all of Apple's bread and butter applications, such as Safari, as they remain unscriptable, for the most part.
Wrapping Up
A huge thanks goes out to the elves here at the MacDevCenter who posted their Macworld wish-lists (in no particular order):
- Ian F. Darwin
- Andrew Anderson
- James Duncan Davidson
- Derrick Story
- Morbus Iff
- Fraser Speirs
- Daniel H. Steinberg
- Josh Paul
And before we retire for the holidays, we'd like to wish you a safe and happy holiday. But before you put your Mac to sleep for the holidays, feel free to post your own wish-list here; what would you like to see announced at the keynote?
And just remember: your Mac will be patiently waiting for you when you return to your office after the holidays. Enjoy the time with friends and family, and we'll see you back here in 2004.
David Miller is combining his passions of photography and working on the web at iStockphoto; when not hacking away with a text editor and a few web browsers in hand, he can be seen huddled over his laptop tweaking levels and curves for his freelance photography. Keep track of David's latest projects over at his home on the web.
Return to the Mac DevCenter.
You must be logged in to the O'Reilly Network to post a talkback.
Showing messages 1 through 47 of 47.
-
Merge iPod with iPhone
2004-02-20 12:15:37 convexcube [Reply | View]
Turn the iPod into a phone as well. Even add a camera and you would have 3 devices in one and wouldnt have to carry so many different things. And add wireless communication between the iPod and other devices, for sync and streaming.... And please, add the ability to Sync Mac to Mac without .Mac in iSync.
-
Hierarchical Playlists/Albums
2004-01-06 23:17:04 jonblock [Reply | View]
Considering the proliferation of iTunes playlists on my system, and the probable explosion of iPhoto albums on others', it would be nice to be able to apply some hierarchical organization to these collections.
For example, I'd like to be able to expand my "Vacations" album group, exposing my last six trip albums, but leave collapsed my "People" and "Hobbies" groups. Right now, I'm stuck scrolling through the long list of playlists, and using convoluted playlist names to keep them grouped together.
Or is this ability already there and I've just missed it?
-
Tabbed termial app
2004-01-06 14:16:04 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
>also, I would like to see a tabbed terminal, like gnome terminal
See iTerm: http://iterm.sf.net/
-
My wishlist
2004-01-05 15:04:30 morwen [Reply | View]
... is simple....
ICQ and Yahoo Messanger support in iChat.
-
My wishlist...
2004-01-05 10:13:55 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
Official support from Apple for the Themes that they've implemented under the cover but refused to provide an interface for... since, what, OS 8.5 or something?
Official support from Apple for the multiple desktop support they include in the OS.
Support for standard UNIX tape drives so that standard UNIX backup software works.
Better integration with foreign file systems and standard UNIX apps. It's great that you can get the resource fork of a file with the "/rsrc" suffix, but you still need to write a lot of code to get at the rest of the file metadata... how about generalising that hook, so you could use "/finf" to get the finder-info, or "/bin" to get the whole thing as an AppleSingle file?
An input manager. Programs register themselves all over the place, with contextual menu extensions, services, keystroke sequences, window corners, and so on. How about giving us a preference pane to manage all this instead of having to deal with all these conflicting programs? I want to be able to put frequently used services in a context menu, and shuffle off some rarely used contextual plugins to the main menu somewhere. I want to be able to start the screensaver with a key combo instead of having to hit that corner of the screen in a hurry. There's just too much stuff to remember, Apple, it's bad enough keeping track of what each app does with option/command/shift click sequences. Remember why you went with a GUI in the first place? Recognition versus recall?
While I think of it, how about letting me clone commonly used menu items into the contextual menu as well? That way I don't have to keep going to the upper left of my 17" display or memorise a command sequence...
Oh, and if I turn on "full keyboard" navigation, I'd like that in Safari as well. :)
-
WishList
2004-01-05 08:40:39 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
I've read a lot of great ideas, and here are some of mine!
1. iOffice with an Accounting program and a spreadsheet based on Improv would be great to round out Keynote.
2. iPod expanded back into PDA land along with with a modular architecture for add-ons like cellular phone, satellite phone, GPS, etc., etc. Thus configurable to customize to user needs, technology advances, and 3rd party developers.
3. Digital Hub expansion to include interfacing with home theatre and pro AV gear. Consider reviving the NeXT name and logo for such a range of products including:
3.1 A range of LCD and/or Plasma Cinema displays capable of HDTV and computer display covering 20, 30, 40, 50, 60 inch size displays. Optional cosmetics for the bezels to include brushed metal, white,...and black
3.2 An AV Mac designed to fit cosmetically with home theatre components, again with the above mentioned cosmetic finish options. The form factor should be the standard 17" with optional rack mount ears available. Consider as well keeping the height to rackmount unit increments.
(Products along these lines are creeping in from the Wintel world, and consider taking a look at the Gateway website).
4. An iMac with a black cosmetic finish.
That's enough from me!
-
Cheaper iPhoto prints
2004-01-05 06:13:00 Chris Adamson |
[Reply | View]
Local photo stores, drug stores, etc., charge about 25c (US) per 4x6 print. iPhoto's price is double that, plus shipping.
-
HDTV?
2004-01-04 21:41:39 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
Hmm... seems to me my Cinema 23HD can handle 1920x1080, and most HDTV isn't even that large.
-
iPBX
2004-01-03 19:48:11 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
In addition to the VoIP mentioned above, PSTN connectity/bridging, voice mail, integration with fax, and *full* VoiceXML capability. I'd be willing to buy an extra the PCI card to upgrade to all this.
-
LiveConnect in Safari
2004-01-03 07:25:22 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
I would like to see Java<->JavaScript communication (LiveConnect) functionality added to Safari. So that at long last a Mac OS X browser became available that for example could easily play 'physlets' (interactive Java applets for introductory physics courses). From an educational point of view that would be a great advantage!
-
ichat headset and retro ipod
2004-01-02 12:09:10 esc [Reply | View]
I would like a bluetooth headset that had a small lcd that gave me my buddy list. Being able to untie myself from my mac for audio iChat AV calls would be a huge thing.
I would also like to see a retro iPod with the generation 1 mechanical wheel. I strongly prefer my 1G iPod over my 3G model ... So how about a 1G with a 40 GB HD. I would even pay a few bucks more.
-
iSync SDK
2004-01-02 10:07:05 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
I'd love to be able to sync with devices/applications/services/data other than the Apple-supported ones. Opening up iSync would further Apple's vision of using the Mac as a hub.
-
Talk/Listen Better
2004-01-02 04:43:15 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
Bluetooth hifi stereo headset with mic, and decent range. Use for iChat/iTunes/iPhone... include a longlife battery or an apple hat with solar panels. iHat!
Multi-party iChat.
Evolve iChat with VoIP and ENUM industry developments.
30" Cinema touchscreen.
More work required on speech recognition across the OS, now that better CPUs are around.
Yeah, simple screen sharing wrapped into iChat. Remember Timbuktu?
George
geo at mac dot com
-
Other thoughts
2003-12-31 14:32:08 vsmith1 [Reply | View]
Requests:
I too would love Apple to get a NetMeeting/H.323/T.120 conferencing tool that is cross-platform compatible with MS offerings. Also can you get more enterprise offerings - such as a SameTime client out of IBM/Lotus?
Extend iDisk style sync to other network file systems.
Get a proper Palm Desktop app that looks after notes/memos to use iSync. Improve the controls iSync. Add handling of ringtones, themes, screensavers, etc. to iSync - the market for ringtones is vast in EU. Maybe tie it in with iTunes?
Responses:
iOffice - as some else has said - AppleWorks is there - it just needs Apple to invest time and effort in it. Rewrite it using XML and within Cocoa. Support it fully with AppleScript and let it do simple presentations if Keynote is not there, but more complex if Keynote is present.
Refusals:
Someone said let iPod stream music using Bluetooth - not fast enough - and what about battery life?
A good year in retrospect and an exciting year in prospect.
Vince
-
Cross-Platform Cocoa
2003-12-31 13:40:26 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
This one is probably the least-likely of all, but it would completely rock my world.
Keeping things the way they are, while not good for me personally, I think is a good move for Apple. Cocoa is so compelling that it a real reason to make mac-only software.
The problem with this is that sometimes that just isn't an option. Just imagine it... one project, windows, linux, mac, and all using the best API available. I know that there are some interesting projects going on, gnustep for example... but its just not the same.
hey, cocoa's roots were cross-platform, so why not :) -
Cross-Platform Cocoa
2004-01-02 16:05:40 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
http://www.gnustep.org -
Cross-Platform Cocoa
2004-04-04 23:16:45 wandy [Reply | View]
"GNUstep provides an object-oriented application framework and tool set for use on a wide variety of computer platforms. GNUstep is based on the original OpenStep specification created by NeXT, Inc. (now Apple). GNUstep is becoming continually more stable and is used in a production environments at several organizations."
Taken from one of their sites.
-
my wishlist
2003-12-31 11:27:09 cesrivas [Reply | View]
1. A much better textedit. come on, gedit is a great test editor. Apple should re-do textedit with a better toolbar and with tabs. Also Textedit should have the options of Syntax Highlighting. also, I would like to see a tabbed terminal, like gnome terminal. gnome is great!
2. Xcode. Code Folding capabilities. Something from kde kate.
3. to add something to your iOffice wishlist. LaTeX based wordprocessing, with a Std and Pro configurations. within the standrad, you can have a standard wordprocessor, but wen you switch to the pro configuration, you will be able to use LaTeX commands in other to have a great document. If you are using the std configuration, you will able to use the control function to show the .tex source-code. LaTeX is great ....
4. iMeeting, iChatPro or AppleRemoteDesktopLite. Something like MS Netmeeting, MS LiveOffice, SGIMeeting, HPVC, SunForum or gnome meeting. ARD is a great app, but true on-line collaboration is a two-way thing. MS Netmeeting is a great app and apple should do a cross-plataform app based in standards. or just name it iChat AV 2.0.You will be able to see somebody else desktop but at the same time, you will be able to video-conf. I know, to much bandwidth, but that will be great
5. woow, a 30-in Cinema Display will be awesome!! 2600 X 1600 woow!!
6. I would like to see Shake with the same GUI that FinalCutPro, DVDStudioPro or Soundtrack. But also, I would not like apple to stop the linux and IRIX dev of Shake.
7. More ProApps! More ProApps!! More ProApps! More ProApps!! More ProApps! More ProApps!! More ProApps! More ProApps!!
8. G5 Xserves, just dual processors & Apple Blade Servers!!! A quad Pro workstation!! woow...(I know a quad G5 is dreaming, but...)
-
My Only Wish
2003-12-31 08:32:08 btraynor [Reply | View]
I only have 1 wish for the coming year and that is for Apple to own up to the iBook screen/logicboard failures that have been plagueing the iBook user community. For an overview of what this is check out the recent Mac.Ars 2003 Review at Ars.Technica found here.
-
My list: iScan
2003-12-31 07:48:15 r_miller [Reply | View]
Here's hoping that iScan will be a physical scanner instead of just software or a plugin, like iSight. Certainly, Apple and Pixar could benefit. I also would like to see a word processor from Apple, but not if it is going to cost over $100. I am more than happy with (http://www.redlers.com) Mellel as a basic and getting ready to kick MS Word's A$$. Also, on my wish list is that Apple not charge us $130 for an upgrade this year!!!!
-
iScan? It's called iMage capture...
2003-12-31 07:27:33 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
An Apple application that can capture images from a TWAIN-compliant scanner? Step forward Image capture, which gained this facility in Mac OS 10.2, Jaguar. At least, so I believe: my hokey old (but with a still-functional 10.1 driver) Agfa SnapScan dose not do TWAIN.
-
Gracefully Stopping The Music...
2003-12-30 22:04:10 jonblock [Reply | View]
I'd like an iTunes button (or menu item) for "stop after this song." Or, expanding on the notion, "stop after x songs."
I'd like to be able to listen to the end of a song, or perhaps a couple of songs, during that "fading out" period before sleep finally comes. But I don't want to let the playlist run all night, and I'd rather not have to create a custom playlist just for the occasion. Just play to a resolve, and stop.
I also tend to leave my iTunes preference set to a long cross-fade between songs. For most of my playlists, that works well. But again, when I'd like to stop listening and move on, I'd rather be able to end at the end of a song, without hearing the next one fade in ("well, I can wait for just one more song...").
Not a priority, but it would be nice to have. -
Gracefully Stopping The Music...
2004-01-02 13:35:50 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
I haven't done it, so I can't weigh in with certainty, but this sounds a LOT like something you should be able to do with AppleScript. iTunes is pretty scriptable. -
Gracefully Stopping The Music...
2003-12-31 13:34:05 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
"Stop after x songs" isn't too hard to do: Create a smart playlist, select "Time is greater than 0:00" and set the playlist to a limit of "x" songs. Unfortunately, since there is no way to make smart playlists "refresh" (i.e., select new songs), you would have to make a new playlist each time you do this.
Still, the "Refresh Smart Playlist(s)" feature is the one I'd like to see in an iTunes refresh; I'm apathetic regarding "Stop after x songs".
-
soft products
2003-12-30 20:47:44 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
The Belkin mediafrob is huge, has batteries, and is generally "wrong". How about software to make the iPod talk to a firewire CF reader? after all, Firewire is symmetric (unlike USB before usb2go.) Once you've got that, software to make plugging an iSight into an iPod work with just a normal cable becomes a *very* interesting next step, and a good lead in to the "video iPod" direction [ie. "why put a highres display on an ipod"...] _Mark_
-
wishlist item
2003-12-30 19:33:17 benry [Reply | View]
I have but one additional wishlist item.
When saving a file I'd like to be able to click on the name of another file to save it with that name. You can do this in Windows and it is a really nice feature for those "save as" tasks. -
wishlist item
2003-12-30 20:19:26 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
You can do this with Panther, can't you?
The filenames are still greyed out in the Save dialog, but you can click on the name.
-
wishlist item
2003-12-31 08:30:36 berhr [Reply | View]
Too bad I don't have my Mac with me right now to double-check, but I think I found such a feature on accident a while back. It was while I was using Panther, but I've never tested to see if Jaguar had it as well. And I haven't tried this trick recently, so my memory isn't especially clear on this.
Anyway, I think command-clicking an existing file will copy its name into the filename box. I seem to remember that just a plain click did not do this, though. I'm pretty sure the modifier was command, although try option or shift if command doesn't work. And maybe I'm off my rocker altogether... :)
-
iPod enhancements
2003-12-30 19:10:26 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
The Belkin voice recorder accessory is really nice, but in addition to the recording functionality being folded into the iPod itself, I'd like to to see voice-to-text implemented seamessly on the mac side. Record notes, dock the ipod and you most recent voice memos are downloaded to the mac and run through the voice recognition software to create written notes.
In the same vein, it would be neat to record hand written notes (bluetooth enable pen with 3D MEMS sensor?) on the pod and have them converted to text on the mother ship upon docking.
-
iPod enhancements
2003-12-30 22:46:33 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
I'd like to see Dolby Headphone implemented for iPods and also for DVD Player.
http://www.dolby.com/dolbyheadphone/
Also I still think that the iPod has many of the pieces to create an iPhone. With GSM on a chip it couldn't be too hard to shoehorn a phone into an iPod form factor.
http://money.cnn.com/2003/03/20/technology/techinvestor/hellweg/index.htm
With contacts already in the iPod, you could use the dial as an input device to 'dial' numbers and with the headset you have a hands free operation with the addition of a microphone to the head set...
Then there would be one less bit of kit to carry around and an iPod would really become indispensible.
-
iOffice = Appleworks
2003-12-30 18:04:44 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
Ahem, heard of Appleworks? Spreadsheet, word processor, database, drawings probably pre-loaded on your machine.
Apple already has a very capable basis for iOffice that just needs some well deserved attention to bring it into direct competition with Office.
Appleworks never really had a decent presentation app, so Keynote fits very logically with the notion, don't you think?
--mco
-
iOffice = Appleworks, well, not exactly
2004-01-04 04:48:30 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
AppleWorks is not a Cocoa app. That leads to a few problems, such as not being able to open UNICODE based text files, not being able to use the character palette, not being able to use all the OS X services like spell checking, and so forth.
Apart from that, it seems that Apple is not going to develop AW much further. International support has stopped all together already (the last updates are only available for Japanese and English versions), and a lot of stability problems and other bugs have not been dealt with at all. Add this to Apple not advertising for AppleWorks anymore, and sure like hell, this looks like no future for AW.
What we need are Cocoa-based apps that integrate nicely, not legacy apps like AW.
--Eric. (former AW user)
-
1 more thing
2003-12-30 16:42:38 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
The number one thing i'd like to see is iTMS being available over here in europe. I'm kind of hopeful as I've read rumors of a iTunes 5.
-
iOffice
2003-12-30 16:32:38 restiffbard [Reply | View]
I second that. I want a great Apple word processor. Texttedit is great but its missing a few dozen things. I hadn't even thought of Account.
I have to say that I'm really liking the names we're giving these fanciful applications. Document, Spreadsheet, Account. Simple, clean, Apple.
Here's to wishing. Only a few more days to go. -
iOffice
2003-12-30 17:05:47 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
Just curious, why focus on iOffice when OpenOffice seems to be growing in popularity, will run on Macs, and for desktop open source software, is amazingly functional and feature rich? -
iOffice
2003-12-30 17:05:34 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
Just curious, why focus on iOffice when OpenOffice seems to be growing in popular, will run on Macs, and for desktop open source software, is amazingly functional and feature rich? -
iOffice
2004-01-01 12:04:06 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
Why coudn't Apple acquire the source to Lotus Improv from IBM? This is already based on the NeXT frameworks/Obj-C and is still considered one of the most revolutionary ideas ever. The fact that it is not available anywhere is a testimony to the power of Obj-C. Apparently, the concepts that make Improv unique are too hard to implement without the technology now known as Cocoa. I would sure hate to see MS's .NET reach the point where Improv reappears there first.
Along with Keynote, a decent WP, and Accounts (cool idea), this would make for an insanely great office suite. -
iOffice
2003-12-30 18:00:27 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
Apple ought to do a nice, Aqua port of OO.O. The current X11 version is very cludgy and horrible to look at. The same, of course, goes for Gimp, but Apple shouldn't piss off Adobe too much.
But, as they have shown with Keynote, they are capable of developing in house office applications that are better than what the Free software community can do. OpenOffice is valuable, but not perfect.
I would really like to see a word processor geared more towards writers than business. Like Ulysses, but smoother, and more intuitive. -
iOffice
2003-12-30 23:45:37 kollivier [Reply | View]
The problem with OpenOffice, and actually the reason we have not seen a native Aqua port already, is that the GUI is emulated, not native. OOo's GUI toolkit is not really designed to give users the native look and feel that Mac users expect - it is designed to provide the same look and feel on every platform. (In fact, the OOo developers are currently trying to create Aqua-looking controls to emulate an Aqua interface, but whether or not the controls will ever behave 100% like native Mac controls is anyone's guess...)
Apple would be better off writing the app from scratch using Cocoa instead of trying to massage OOo's VCL to work with Aqua. They could of course incorporate some of the particularly useful bits of code. -
iOffice
2003-12-31 01:41:50 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
If cost is the larger issue, and speaking for myself, it usually is, what is the big deal about having the existing OpenOffice GUI less the native Aqua controls? Other than looks, is there that much difference to the average consumer in the bottom line usefulness of this program given its free price? Mabye it's a matter of education, and people understanding there is something for free, with a hidden cost, i.e. things don't look "pretty". OpenOffice may look a bit generic, but it's not that bad. -
iOffice
2003-12-31 20:49:30 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
The problem I see with Open Office for the Mac is its size, load time, and the fact that some of it's dialog boxes (such as save )don't always have the buttons labelled (intermittently). Also, on a single Mac with mutltiple user accounts it is necessary to configure .rc files for each account -- not something the average user will want to do.
Also, last I checked the Aqua Dev track was essentially moribund with a target of 2006 (yes, six) for the first Aqua release.
rjv -
iOffice
2003-12-30 21:06:31 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
Considering OSS achilles heal has long been usuable desktop productivity software for the so-called "point and drool" masses, I'd say OpenOffice looks like an amazing first step in the right direction. Personaly, I don't find its interface horrible to look at, and so far it's never crashed on me and has successfully imported all my .doc files with one exception, which was a document that had an embedded MS Visio file. The Excel piece looks pretty much like the real deal, at least from a usability standpoint, and the Word clone seems pretty decent. And, after all, it is free. I don't know how much something like iOffice would go for, but I can say that I'm highly inclined to make do with OpenOffice if the price is anywhere near what I think it would be. Don't get me wrong, I'm a fan of Keynote - it's a pretty good tool from what I can tell, and I'm not a OSS zealot, I just like the idea of usuable software that isn't going to wipe out my piggy bank.
-
My wishlist
2003-12-30 15:30:32 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
There's no doubt 2003 was a great year for new products, but the quality control left a lot to be desired. Display problems have plagued both the Powerbook (white spots) and iBook (death), and 10.2.8 was a shambles. I'm delighted to see a resurgent Apple, and I'd love to see a year free from major hardware or software problems.
And get rid of the brushed Metal interface! -
Quality Control Problems?
2004-01-03 21:38:07 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
I'd be interested in real numbers for the iBook problem - the fact is that over 4% of computers fail completely in the first month (over 10% of Compaqs fail in the first month), and that 10% require some sort of repair.
http://www.consumerreports.org/main/detailv3.jsp?CONTENT%3C%3Ecnt_id%20=305449
Apple's quality control is still excellent. The issue is the horribly high rates of failure in the industry as a whole. With a device as complex as a modern laptop, you're not going to get "a year free from major hardware or software problems".





