For the last five days, I’ve been near-obsessively refreshing the FedEx website, hoping for news of the whereabouts of my new computer. I’m transitioning away from a work-owned PowerBook G4 1.5Ghz, and into a MacBook Pro 1.83Ghz of my very own. This morning, when the knocking came at 8am, I was convinced it was anyone but the FedEx guy delivering my computer, as we all know that FedEx’s modus operandi is something on the order of overpromise and underdeliver, but there he was, dropping off the tiny box that I couldn’t believe actually held my computer.
To my shock and awe, there it was. The box itself is half as thin, and only slightly taller than the PowerBook boxes I’ve come so used to unpacking. Nestled within its polysterene innards was my computer, its monumental power adapter, a few discs, a remote and a display adapter. These are my first thoughts, from unpack to working system, are contained within.
The Packaging
Much has been made of the packaging of the MacBook Pro, as it’s a radical departure from the packaging of the previous PowerBook models. The box itself is barely 4″ deep, and probably only a few inches taller than the older model box. There’s certainly less styrofoam as well, molded into two flat sections that form the next for the PowerBook and its accessories. Gone is the medium format paper manual, as well, replaced by a manual that fits easily within the DVD package box, along with the smaller warranty papers. The intricate pattern on the top of the box makes a tempting grab point for removing the top panel, but sadly, this just ends up damaging the pattern. I managed to pop out a couple of the nice new patterned sections before I gripped it by the edge and popped it open that way.
Booting
The theme of the day begins here, as pressing the power button triggered both the screen lighting up and the power chime, in that order. Granted, light does travel faster than sound, but wow, that’s pretty amazing. Once pressed, it’s about 30 seconds from power on to setup screen. Not at all shabby when you think that my old powerbook’s boot time was measured in minutes, and not seconds.
Applications
Safari was the first application that I tried, and the first jaw-dropping discovery of the improvements made by the CoreDuo chipset. One bounce. Correction, half a bounce. By the time the Safari icon had risen to its apex, I had an open window, and by the time it had fallen back to the Dock, the page was half loaded. Not at all shabby. Next, I logged into my TypePad account, and prepared to wait for the SSL side of things to take effect. Much to my surprise, the login was nearly instant, and not nearly as slow as it had been prior to Safari for PowerPC. Subsequent pages and sites also loaded very quickly, much more so than in previous versions.
Mail shows a bit of improvement as well, but it’s much harder to tell what’s faster, though Search appears to be a bit zippier.
Dashboard is much improved for the Intel Mac, springing forth quickly and cleanly, unlike its invocation on my old PowerBook, which took an unacceptable amount of time, and did so in a jerky hurdy-gurdy fashion. The new, improved Dashboard will likely become a staple for me, where before I was unhappy to have to use it.
Microsoft Office are clearly Rosetta apps, and it shows. Memory Usage goes up, Speed goes down. It’s not a fatal flaw, but it’s enough to remind me to keep it shut when it’s not being used. I have a feeling this bodes not so well for Photoshop and other similar applications
Conclusions
Though it’s been just a few short hours getting things going, I’m very impressed with the MacBook Pro, which runs at a lightning pace compared to my 2 year old PowerBook G4.


Well, well, faster than a G4 heh! And is it worth the almost double price compared to a dual core Vaio?
I sure think so, but then again, you might *like* running Windows.
And the only VAIO I can find with a proper CoreDuo chip and a 15" screen is the FE590PB, the rest have old Pentium Ms....Apple and Oranges...and if it doesn't run (non-pirated) OS X, I don't want it.
Great to hear that you are enjoying your new MacBook Pro, Tom. I've got hopes of purchasing one soon - and it is really helpful to hear of your experiences.
You might be a Mac user if you obsess with the packaging.
The Sony VGN-FE590GC ($1650) is the closest to a MacBook Pro, of course it is bigger, heavier, and has Intel onboard video (with shared memory!) so don't expect to ever do anything with graphics or play modern video games. It doesn't even come with Windows XP Pro! And while they are both 15" screens, the Apple LCD is higher resolution (1440x900 vs 1280x800).
So the Apple is smaller, lighter, faster, more capable and costs a few hundred dollars more. Even between Sony models, it is normal for faster, smaller, lighter laptops to cost more.
Great to hear that the low-end MacBook Pro delivers a significant performance increase to a 1.5GHz PowerBook. I'm currently running a 1GHz Ti PowerBook and am waiting until (I think) next year for a Merom-based MacBook Pro with the Santa Rosa chipset, so I should see a LOT of improvements.
It is interesting that whenever a new Mac is released that non-Mac users appear surprised that Mac-users are happy to pay a price premium for their products. Since my switch from XP a few years ago I have come to appreciate that the price is well worth paying for years of hassle-free computing and an overall experience that other platforms just can't touch yet.
These are exciting times for Mac users. Really, the justification for running Windows is coming down to 'corporate standard', 'legacy apps' or 'games'. That's right - against Mac OS X on intel, I really think you need to come up with a solid business reason for even contemplating a Windows machine - and don't forget to factor in the extra maintenance costs.
I'm torn between the MacBook Pro and the VAIO FE590G. The VAIO appears to have a LOT of advantages (lower cost gets twice the RAM, it includes a modem, and a double layer DVD burner). The MacBook is not even a pound lighter and has some nifty things like the remote and MagSafe power cord. But I'm very concerned about the Rosetta performance, and I love my PhotoShop.
I think I just made my decision for myself. :)
We here in the repair sector call it the Powerbook Evolution.
:D
My MacBook showed up on Tuesday. Some things are faster (Mail, Safari, Ruby) but on the whole it is clear that they have some bugs to iron out within OS X itself. Finder performance is subpar (even with an upgraded BTO spindle), init of Preview is pokey and my airport selections will randomly crap out. I do love how much faster what I compile with gcc runs.