Women in Technology

Hear us Roar



Article:
  The REST of the Web
Subject:   Dedicated solutions
Date:   2006-05-11 14:28:00
From:   jrbriggs
Response to: Dedicated solutions

Hi


Yes I came across both Restlet and XINS a while ago. I remain unsure whether Restlets really add enough to the mix to be interesting, given that one can do everything with a basic servlet plus additional libraries. But then I'm deeply suspicious of anything advertising itself as a "framework", so perhaps that's just me. ;-)


XINS is not REST, despite the fact that it advertises its "REST" protocol. Based on my quick double-check of the documentation, it uses GET and POST, combined with a parameter to indicate the function. So basically RPC, rather than REST.


Regards,
Jason

Full Threads Oldest First

Showing messages 1 through 2 of 2.

  • Dedicated solutions
    2006-09-18 13:43:37  czerwonka [View]

    REST is not a standard and if the implementation is based on web resources, then it's REST afaic.
    • Dedicated solutions
      2006-09-24 02:23:19  jrbriggs [View]

      Not quite, IMO. One of the aspects of REST is uniform interfaces that apply to all resources (ref: http://rest.blueoxen.net/cgi-bin/wiki.pl?ShortSummaryOfRest) -- given that restriction, a resource that can be interfaced via a wide variety of verbs (ala RPC), which are different from the verbs of another resource, doesn't satisfy the requirements as I see them.