Nested Classes, Part 1
Subject:   Accessing Protected Members
Date:   2004-05-18 21:28:10
From:   bdell
Response to: Accessing Protected Members

I placed BasicMonitorScreen in package package1 and ColorMonitorScreen in package package2 and it still compiles. I also tried 1.4.2 and it works there as well. Perhaps I am misunderstanding what the "other" class is.

Given the way inner classes are implemented, it seems natural to provide access as the accessor method the inner class depends on would have access to protected members of the enclosing class's super-class and, as I wrote before, it seems consistent with the definition of protected access. I couldn't find anything in the Java Language Specification that said protected members in this circumstance shouldn't be accessible.

Full Threads Newest First

Showing messages 1 through 1 of 1.

  • Accessing Protected Members
    2004-05-21 15:42:38  kristianmonsen [View]

    I understand it so that if the enclosing class can access the variable, than the inner class can as well. Since the enclosing class is a subclass of the class where the variable is declared, it will always be able to access a protected variable.