Unfinished Business Part 2: Closing the Circle
Subject:   Off-Topic
Date:   2003-07-15 06:03:55
From:   anonymous2
Response to: Off-Topic

"I delete off topic and impolite posts. Questions and comments about the article are welcome. Personal disagreements with the author are not."

This is not off-topic, impolite or due to a "personal" disagreement.

The reference to his other work is not off-topic because it reflects that this is not the first time the author's expertise has been questioned through reader response to his work. Many of the statements in these two articles are blatantly false and should not attempted to be passed along as anything else.

I guess a new question comes to many times will support articles/books from a particular author whose expertise is continually questioned by readers before it is suggested that he be a little more professional?

Main Topics Oldest First

Showing messages 1 through 1 of 1.

  • Off-Topic
    2003-07-15 09:15:49  chromatic | O'Reilly AuthorO'Reilly Blogger [View]

    These two articles aren't really about Active Directory or eDirectory. They're about the challenges people face while migrating large business networks to Linux. That said, I've asked David to explore eDirectory in his next article. If it solves the problems he brings up in these two articles, it's well-worth an article.

    As to questioning an author's research or conclusions, that's one reason we have talkbacks enabled. That goes for any author. If you have hard numbers as to deployment rates of one product versus the other, by all means please post them -- but I'm going to need something stronger than opinion.