Article:
  Daddy, Are We There Yet? A Discussion with Alan Kay
Subject:   Interesting... but how?
Date:   2003-04-05 11:39:43
From:   anonymous2
Response to: Interesting... but how?

Previous poster wrote:


> how is typing a bunch of formulas into a computer any
> better than memorizing them? In either case, the student
> has no direct personal experience with the principles involved.


This is exactly the point Kay's work has addressed over the past thirty years. Writing a program is not a means to some other, pre-defined end, in exactly the same way that writing a piece of music is not a means to an end. Writing the program, like composing the music, like any other sophisticated, structured creative activity, is about exploring the world and how we can know it. Kay's work points out that computing is a way of knowing the world in the same way that music is a wayt of knowing the world. Forget the means-ends trap and you begin to see what he's been on about all this time.


Full Threads Oldest First

Showing messages 1 through 1 of 1.

  • Interesting... but how?
    2003-04-05 19:25:30  anonymous2 [View]

    Play with Squeak (or with the stuff at Squeakland) and you'll soon get the idea. I'm a hopeless programmer, but Squeak has been the only language (or maybe I should say the only dialect) that I've really enjoyed and made useful stuff with.

    The music analogy is pretty apt: last time I heard, AK was constructing some kind of pipe organ......