View Review Details


Book:   FileMaker Pro 10: The Missing Manual
Subject:   Not up to the Pogue standard
Date:   2009-09-11 07:36:16
From:   Anonymous Reader
Response to: Not up to the Pogue standard

Rating:  StarStarStarStarStar

I'd have to agree with this review, I've been using Filemaker on and off for a while but wanted to get into the relational side more after I'd constructed a few databases.


There is some useful information in this book, I started with chapter 7 and it explains how to model your data. From then on it gets into the detective agency example and quickly loses the reader.


I had to go and look for the downloaded examples to try and make sense of what was being written. I'm happy to follow a book building my own copy of the database that they describe and then use it for the next chapter. You can't do that with this book as the example files for the next chapter contain more work in them than is explained in the book. This slows you down as you have to try and work out what the changes are and what they are for.


I still haven't worked out how the detective agency databsae is supposed to work or what it is trying to achieve. Too many jumps without a suitable explanation make it very hard to understand.


What's a line item, how is that different to an expense and why does it have an invoice ID? I can see what you're trying to get at but not being an accountant doesn't make following the example easy at all.


The style of the book is a bit like being in a room with 5 different people talking at the same time, there are too many unrelated examples littering the page and because of that you find yourself having to refer to diagrams several pages forward or back from where you are in the book.


I have other Missing Manual books and I don't feel that this is up to the same standard.

Full Threads Oldest First
  • Not up to the Pogue standard,  September 11 2009
    Submitted by Anonymous Reader   [Respond | View]

    Dear Reader,

    Thank you for taking the time to review FileMaker Pro 10: The Missing Manual. We are planning to revise the entire text, including the example databases, for the next edition. Thank you for being so specific in pointing out where you had problems; this helps us know what needs the most improvement.

    I'm sorry that the book did not meet your expectations.

    Nan Barber
    editor