View Review Details
| Book: |
|
Statistics in a Nutshell |
| Subject: |
|
Not a "Nutshell" book and riddled with errors |
| Date: |
|
2009-04-28 16:36:20 |
| From: |
|
dyoung
|
|
|
I had high hopes for this book. The world really needs a reference guide for those of us who have had exposure to statistics in college, but often don't remember which tool to turn to (t-test? F-test? Chi-square? a non-parametric test? I don't remember which to use when!). It would have been perfect to provide handy reference tables for which tools to look into in various circumstances, along with the assumptions that must be met to use that tool and a reference to a page number where the tool is briefly explained with some examples. I would have been happy to use this to get me started and then google for more detailed information.
This isn't that book. There are no handy reference tables (of any sort) in this book.
Despite the "Nutshell" title, this book is written as if it is a linear, beginner primer on statistics.
I could be OK with that if it were a good beginner primer on statistics. Instead, the authors seem to assume that "Nutshell" in the title is a license to cut corners in their explanations, leaving the beginning reader confused.
The worst part is that the book is riddled with errors. If you're trying to follow the examples and learn from them, you're never sure if you just don't understand or if this is yet another typo/error. Chapter 8 on t-test is so full of computation errors and typos that I doubt it was ever proof-read.
|
"...a book worth having for anyone who must deal with numbers and statistics. The truth is we all deal with numbers and statistics in our everyday lives."
--Tom Hrach, Memphis PC Users Group, The Bridge, January/February 2009, Volume 25, Number 1
-
Re: Not a "Nutshell" book and riddled with errors, June 29 2009
Submitted by
Sarah Boslaugh |
[Respond | View]
We are sorry that Statistics in a Nutshell did not meet your expectations. It is meant to be a handbook for people who need an introduction to the world of statistics or who had a class years ago but need to remind themselves of what they learned. It's not a guide to research design (which is where you would expect to find information about "which test to use when"). The errors have been corrected in a reprint edition which will be available on August 5.
-
Re: Not a "Nutshell" book and riddled with errors, August 14 2009
Submitted by Anonymous Reader [Respond | View]
Is the second printing available? How can one distinguish between the first and second printing in a bookstore?
Thanks!
-
Third printing, August 25 2009
Submitted by
Sarah Boslaugh |
[Respond | View]
The most recent printing is the third, in July 2009. If you look on the copyright page under "Print History" it will say the month and year the book was printed.
-
Re: Not a "Nutshell" book and riddled with errors, July 30 2009
Submitted by Anonymous Reader [Respond | View]
I saw this title in a store recently and it looked useful.
If I buy the pdf version now, will it incorporate the error corrections you said would be in the Aug. 5 edition?
Thanks!
-
PDF of Statistics in a Nutshell, August 25 2009
Submitted by
Sarah Boslaugh |
[Respond | View]
Yes, the pdf version incorporates the corrections.