View Review Details


Book:   JavaScript: The Missing Manual
Subject:   More about jQuery then about JavaScript
Date:   2009-01-11 12:21:06
From:   Kasper
Rating:  StarStarStarStarStar

Personally, I was having high expectations of JavaScript: The Missing Manual. I was hoping for an improvement on my client-side scripting, an aspect of webprogramming on which I have always been lacking skills. Unfortunately, this book failed to do so. Contrary to what is on the front or back of the book, it's main content is how to use a javascript framework (i.e. jQuery) to implement certain nice and/or useful features on your website. However, I was already using a framework (prototype/script.aculo.us) to get those neat 'web 2.0 artwork', but I wanted to be able to write my own framework. Besides that, why would I switch from prototype/script.aculo.us to jQuery?


So, in the end, only the first few chapters which explain in general the working and syntax of JavaScript were good for me. I had already read some about that, but it was a good opportunity to freshen up that knowledge. But if you're really looking for something to learn JavaScript from, leave this book on its shelf. However, if you're looking for a way to get fancy websites fast using jQuery, this could be just the book for you!

Full Threads Oldest First
  • a good read,  January 21 2009
    Rating: StarStarStarStarStar
    Submitted by leocullen   [Respond | View]

    I feel the Kasper's review is overly negative so to be fair and balance things up I give this book 5 stars - granted, I have only read the first 5 chapters but so far the writing is engaging, concepts are explained clearly and the material seems to be well organised and the tutorials are entertaining and its clear some work has gone into them. As a book for getting things done it excels - if a library exists eith the code you need why waste time reinventing the wheel? If you need an exhaustive account of javascript's features there is 'the definitive guide'. On the strength of the first 5 chapters I bought David Mac Sawyer's 'CSS, the missing manual'. If you're looking for a book to get you into javascript and and putting it to work making your sites look good I say go for it. When I have finished the book I'll try to give an updated review, time permitting.