View Review Details


Book:   Game Coding Complete
Subject:   Great but Flawed
Date:   2007-07-03 16:55:22
From:   merrod
Rating:  StarStarStarStarStar

A wide ranging coverage of the game programming reality, with example code in the text. The level of this code is equivelant to the game programming gems series genrally being more practical and less academic. The FLAW and its a big one is the lack of code, no CD and the auther explaines at lenght that to give the best upto date working code only a well maintained web site will do. He also expresses exasperation at poor code in other titles. Well he beats that, what about no code at all. web site inaccessable. no links and no replies from seller auther or publisher. If you want a great book with NO CODE and a lot of typing then this is for you. I myself have found the complete lack of code too annoying. If you bought the book for typing practice then all is well. I rate this a 5* if the code was avalible and 0* as it stands. My advice for what its worth is dont buy it untill you check out the web site and the code promised in the book is avalible.
Full Threads Oldest First
  • Great but Flawed,  October 05 2007
    Rating: StarStarStarStarStar
    Submitted by Anonymous Reader   [Respond | View]

    The book is great but you really need the source code if someone has a copy i would be really grateful if someone could send it or point out where i can get it from. In fact if i could get a copy i would set up a website to permanently host it for anyone else searching for a copy.
    • Great but Flawed,  March 05 2008
      Rating: StarStarStarStarStar
      Submitted by Anonymous Reader   [Respond | View]

      I haven't bought this yet, but I just wanted to say that the source code is available before I forget. It seems a bad trend in a lot of books I read to leave off the fact that they have a website, most do so it's a good idea to look for one.

      The website for this book is located here
      http://www.mcshaffry.com/GameCode/

      All source code can be obtained there.

      (if I read it and want to lower my 5 star rating I'll come back)