View Review Details


Book:   Programming Python
Subject:   Programming Python, 2nd Edition Review
Date:   2001-06-12 09:40:23
From:   Joakim Hove
Rating:  StarStarStarStarStar

This book was a great disappointment to me. My major gripes with the book


are:



  1. Very windows centric, spesific platform issues could have been


    handled isolated in one chapter.


  2. Extremely "wordy" - the page count could have


    been cut down to the half without reducing actual content. Most of the


    examples are introduced in an incremental fashion, with several different


    script version accomplishing approximately the same thing, all printed with


    source code and full display of user interaction.


  3. The index is close to useless. There is no way


    to find an example demonstrating a particular Python feature by looking up


    a keyword in the index.


  4. There is no explanation of Python concepts, only examples,


    examples, examples and examples ... In my opinion the point of examples is


    to demonstrate a concept - however in this book the examples seem to be the


    most important in their own right.


  5. The chapters give only a very vague indication of which python


    concepts will be covered - or what would you expect to find in the chapters


    called Larger system examples I and Larger system examples


    II
    ?.



      Maybe the problem for me is that the book was something completely


      different from what I expected. A more suitable title than "Programming


      Python" would have been "Python Examples", "Problem solving using Python"


      or something like that.


      Instead of bying this book I would recommend "Learning Python" by the same


      author, which is a really good book.



See larger cover